The restoration of the Assumption of the Virgin and Saints by the workshop of Sandro Botticelli
WORK
Assumption of the Virgin and Saints
ARTIST
Workshop of Sandro Botticelli
DATE
Early decades of the sixteenth century
TECHNICAL DESCRIPTION
Tempera and gold on panel
Dimensions: 178 x 88.2 x 3.5 cm
owner
Complesso Monumentale della Pilotta, Parma
Provenance
Complesso Monumentale della Pilotta, Parma
Project Period
2019 - 2021
ASSUMPTION OF THE VIRGIN AND SAINTS, WORKSHOP OF SANDRO BOTTICELLI
The restoration of the panel Assumption of the Virgin with Saints Benedict, Thomas and Julian by the Workshop of Sandro Botticelli, owned by the Complesso Monumentale della Pilotta in Parma, was carried out by Open Care’s Conservation and Restoration Department as part of the second edition of the Lucida Call, launched in 2019.
The Lucida Call, promoted by Open Care and Factum Foundation, was created to offer institutions an integrated project of analysis, conservation and restoration of a work of significant historical and artistic interest, through the use of the Lucida 3D digital scanner.
The Lucida Call was launched in 2015 on the initiative of Open Care – Servizi per l’Arte and Factum Foundation. It is open to public and private museum institutions in northern Italy and aims to offer an integrated project of analysis, conservation and restoration of a work of significant historical and artistic interest, through the use of the Lucida 3D digital scanner.
The second edition of the Call was launched in 2019 with the support of Euromobiliare Advisory Sim. The winning work is the Assumption of the Virgin with Saints Benedict, Thomas and Julian, attributed to the workshop of Sandro Botticelli and owned by the Complesso Monumentale della Pilotta in Parma.
The winning institution was selected by an independent scientific committee made up of Giorgio Bonsanti, former superintendent of the Opificio delle Pietre Dure and Professor of History and Technique of Restoration at the Universities of Turin and Florence; Fernando Mazzocca, Full Professor of Museology and of Art and Restoration Criticism at the Università degli Studi di Milano; and Roeland Kollewijn, an expert in Old Master paintings and drawings and a member of the RICS (Royal Institution of Chartered Surveyors).
The scientific committee, chaired by Bonsanti, stated:
The painting, certainly executed by Botticelli’s workshop, is of significant historical and artistic interest and urgently requires restoration, of both the painted surface and the wooden support. The analyses and research supported by the project may corroborate the hypothesis of direct intervention by the artist, at least in the compositional design.
After being transported from its place of conservation to Open Care’s laboratories in Milan, the selected work underwent in-depth diagnostic investigations and a targeted conservation treatment, which was completed in 2021.
Condition of the work:
The work, a tempera grassa on panel, has undergone several layered restoration treatments over the years, which affected the wooden support but, above all, the decorative layers, in an uneven manner.
Wood’s lamp examination helped to distinguish different types of chromatic retouching. Some of it was carried out over the final glossy protective layer: it appears darker and can be traced to a more recent intervention. Other retouching, beneath the varnish, results from a much earlier intervention and has taken on a fluorescence not very different from that of the original colors.
The varnish mainly shows a greenish-yellow fluorescence, alternating with areas of warmer fluorescence scattered unevenly across the whole surface, attributable to an old varnish that was removed incompletely and haphazardly. There are also areas whose fluorescence is so amber-colored as to suggest a patina applied to conceal exposed areas or disguise retouching. The protective coatings were applied unevenly, even leaving drips, for example near the lower right corner, and various oxidations are also visible, most evident in the dark areas of color.
Isabella Villafranca Soissons, Director of Open Care’s Conservation and Restoration Department, explains: “The panel of the Assumption had been completely repainted, but with such precision that not even the thorough diagnostic campaign we had carried out revealed the three successive layers. After consolidating and stabilizing the work, we therefore carried out three levels of cleaning of the paint surface, encouraged by Simone Verde, director of the Pilotta, and beautiful colors emerged: Saint Thomas’s robe is now a vivid green, and Saint Julian’s has gone from brownish to blue. The work certainly came out of Botticelli’s workshop, because the three methods of preparatory drawing (incision; pouncing, which is not so common on panels; and brush drawing) are perfectly consistent. Doubts remain about the master’s personal involvement, although the quality of the figure of Saint Julian (and, in my opinion, that of the Virgin as well) is extremely high. This will be discussed at a study day.”
The restored work will be presented in early 2022 and will subsequently be returned to, and displayed in, the Complesso Monumentale della Pilotta in Parma.





